Fentress Blog

How Courthouse Design Shapes the Jury Experience

Written by Masha Casey | Nov 13, 2024

Courthouse design is more than architectural aesthetics or functional layouts—it plays a powerful role in shaping the experiences of those who enter, especially jurors. As I recently discovered during my time on jury duty, the design of these spaces can influence everything from a juror’s comfort and focus to their sense of responsibility and impartiality.

In a place where justice is sought and decisions are made, every detail of the environment subtly communicates to jurors, impacting not only how they feel but how they perform their crucial civic duty. Here’s what I learned about how courthouse design truly shapes the jury experience.

Jury Check-In Process

From the moment I received my Juror Summons, I was excited to see how a courthouse operates from the juror’s perspective. On my scheduled day, I entered through a modern security screening area featuring X-ray machines, magnetometers, and friendly security personnel who created a welcoming atmosphere. 

The check-in process, with clerks stationed at a desk behind orderly queue barriers, felt seamless, much like an airport. A monitor played videos about maintaining impartiality, setting the tone for our role.

Efficient, well-organized entry points not only reduced juror anxiety but also helped everyone enter quickly and safely, ensuring that courthouse operations ran smoothly and that people could focus on their duties.

Key elements that are helpful in the jury check-in process:

  • Providing sufficient space for the cueing of jurors through courthouse security
  • Having security personnel placed to put jurors at ease when going through the security checkpoint
  • Providing a well-organized jury check-in guide

Juror Lounges: Enhancing Comfort and Convenience

To my surprise, I arrived during Juror Appreciation Week, where the juror lounge was decorated with balloons, coffee, and snacks. The lounge itself was spacious and well-equipped, with large screens showing informational videos, tables for working, and even a small business center for quieter tasks. Thoughtful amenities like these helped jurors feel comfortable and prepared, especially for long waits.

The juror lounge design spoke volumes about how designers or courthouse staff prioritize juror needs. Offering conveniences like workspaces, refreshments, and accessible information creates a welcoming atmosphere and makes waiting more productive since not every juror will be called for duty.

Key elements for a comfortable and convenient juror lounge:

  • Designing sufficient space with instructions on large monitors and comfortable chairs
  • Having adequate workspaces with powered desks, Wi-Fi, and a business center
  • Providing an easily accessible break room with refreshments or kitchenette to store or prepare food

Jury Circulation: How Design Affects Juror Movement and Safety

When I was selected for the trial, I became acutely aware of how the courthouse layout affects juror movement and safety. Each day, the jury was escorted by a clerk from a private jury deliberation room to the courtroom. 

In this particular courthouse, jurors, staff, and even prisoners sometimes shared the same hallway, which required constant coordination from the security team to avoid unwanted encounters with defendants. This lack of distinct pathways delayed proceedings and made it clear how crucial dedicated circulation paths are for efficiency and security.

Design should prioritize the separation of routes for different user groups to minimize contact between jurors, staff, judges, prisoners and other courthouse attendees for their safety, security, and mental wellbeing.

Key Elements for Secure Circulation:

  • Constructing private, secure paths for juror movement to avoid encounters with defendants or the public
  • Designing juror deliberation rooms away from public spaces behind restricted access points

Placement of Defense and Prosecution Tables

When we entered the courtroom, we had to walk past the defendant and attorneys’ tables, which created a very intimidating atmosphere. The jury entry shouldn't require jurors to pass by the defendant’s attorney's table to avoid any appearance of bias. Keeping distance helps ensure impartiality and fairness in court proceedings.

Another aspect of the layout that stood out was the proximity of the defense and prosecution tables to one another which were separated only by a lectern. This close seating arrangement created a somewhat tense atmosphere during the entire trial between the two parties.

Such details can influence the mood and dynamics in the courtroom. Designers might consider more spatial separation between the two sides to reduce tension, especially in criminal trials, where the stakes are high, and emotions can run strong. The traditional approach of placing two tables both facing the judge is ideal in this scenario.

Layout Recommendations:

  • Placing the defense and prosecution tables in front of the judge with enough space between them to allow private conversations and avoid close proximity to the defendant
  • Having the jury entrance to the courtroom on the same side as the jury box  to avoid crossing through the well area

The Jury Box and Courtroom Layout: Supporting Juror Focus

The jury box setup greatly impacts how jurors view the evidence and follow the trial. In our courtroom, the jury box had comfortable, spacious seating, a slightly raised platform, and an unobstructed view of the judge, witnesses, and attorneys. The courtroom had large screens for document display through which the attorneys and clerks shared evidence, which worked well, though smaller monitors within the jury box would have allowed us to follow evidence more closely.

This experience highlighted how design choices affect juror focus and comprehension, such as seat positioning, sightlines, and technology placement.

Key elements for Jury Box and Courtroom Layout

  • Providing a jury box with clear sightlines of the judge, witness box, defendant and prosecution tables
  • Having comfortable chairs on two levels; one for handicap accessibility and the other on a raised platform to support sightlines.
  • Providing monitors in the jury box for evidence review

Final Takeaways: Why Courthouse Design Matters for Jurors

Reflecting on my jury duty experience, it’s clear that courthouse design isn’t just an architectural detail—it’s a crucial element in supporting the justice process. Every space, from the check-in area to the jury box, has the potential to impact how jurors feel and function in their roles. 

Thoughtfully designed courthouses can foster comfort, impartiality, and security, enabling jurors to focus on their civic duties without unnecessary stress or distractions. As we continue to prioritize fair and efficient legal processes, it’s essential to consider how courthouse design can elevate the experience for all involved, ensuring that spaces dedicated to justice truly support the people who uphold it.